Prof. Ian Boyd appeared before the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee (EFRACOM) on the 31st of January 2018 to discuss his work as Defra Chief Scientific Adviser.

Professor Boyd was one of the principal author’s of the recently-published ‘From Waste to Resource Productivity’ report which emphasised the importance of moving away from incineration and landfill and towards more efficient and sustainable uses of resources. This report will provide an important part of the evidence base for the Government’s forthcoming Resources and Waste Strategy, due out in the second half of 2018.

You can listen to Prof. Ian Boyd speak critically about incineration from around from 15:17:12 at http://www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/9c6b4590-5882-4464-a945-29783d4af339

Prof. Boyd explains how: “If there is one way of extinguishing the value of the materials fast, its to stick it in an incinerator and burn it. Now it may give you energy at the end of the day, but actually some of those materials, even if they are plastics, with a little bit of ingenuity, can be given more positive value. And one of the things that worries me is that we are taking these materials, we’re putting them in incinerators, we’re losing them forever, and actually we’re creating carbon dioxide out of them as well, which is not a great thing, when in fact we could be long-term storing them until we have the innovative technologies to re-use them and to turn them into something that is more positively valued. And this brings me to a more general point about landfill… landfill is actually a very low marginal-cost method for storing materials – highly resistant materials such as plastics and metals – for a long period of time. If we cannot extract the value from them now, so one caveat I would put around the current direction of travel on landfill, is that we shouldn’t lose sight of the fact that in a few decades time, or maybe a bit longer, we might be mining our landfill sites for the resources they contain, and rather than put some of those resources into incinerators and just lose them forever we might want to think differently about the landfill sites.” (15:17:12)

He later stated: “I think that incineration, and this is a personal view, I think incineration is not a good direction to go in. I think that if you are investing many tens of millions, hundreds of millions, in urban waste incineration plants – and those plants are going to have a 30 to 40 year lifespan – you have to have the waste streams to keep them supplied. Now that is the market pull on waste, so it encourages the production of waste, it encourages the production of residual waste, it encourages people to think that we can throw what could be potentially valuables materials if we were to think about them innovatively into a furnace and burn them.” (15:20:50)

Boyd also cited how Sweden’s pursuit of incineration may have encouraged the production of residual waste and he explained how historic UK waste policy encouraging incineration over landfill may have created perverse outcomes.

EFRACOM’s Chair Neil Parish MP compared incineration with diesel as an option that was once promoted as being environmentally friendly but that is now being seen increasingly as a mis-step that is bad for the environment.

Later in the discussion, Prof. Boyd indicated that an incineration tax and a moratorium on new incinerators were worth considering as means to promote recycling alongside investing in innovative recycling processes and ‘designing out’ waste as part of a holistic approach to resource management.

Incineration criticised at Westminster Forum circular economy event

Concerns about incineration were expressed by respected waste figures at a Westminster Energy, Environment & Transport Forum Keynote Seminar on “Priorities for UK waste and recycling policy and developing the circular economy” that took place in London. Around two hundred delegates gathered on Thursday, 18th January 2018 to hear MPs and speakers from across the […]

Full Story

UKWIN calls on NIC to accept end of the line for incineration

In a heavy-hitting 15-page submission to the National Infrastructure Commission (NIC), UKWIN calls for the NIC’s investigation into infrastructure capacity requirements to accept that we have reached the end of the line when it comes to building new incineration capacity in the UK.

Full Story

UKWIN nominated for ‘Hot 100’ award

UKWIN’s National Coordinator Shlomo Dowen is one of several ‘anti-incineration’ and ‘pro Zero Waste’ nominees for Resource Magazine’s Hot 100 award. For details on the nominees and instructions for voting please visit http://hot100.resource.co/ or vote for Shlomo directly via http://hot100.resource.co/nominee/shlomo-dowen NOTE: You are entitled to vote for multiple nominees, you just need to vote for one at […]

Full Story

UKWIN to speak at London Assembly Incineration Meeting

On Thursday 7th December 2017 the London Assembly’s Environment Committee will be discussing issues relating to incineration as part of the Committee’s investigation into waste management in London. Shlomo Dowen, the National Coordinator of the UK Without Incineration Network (UKWIN), will be one of the guest attending the meeting. UKWIN has provided written evidence to […]

Full Story

Ask your MP to support a ban on new incinerators!

There is now more committed incineration capacity than genuinely residual waste to burn, so it is vital that we stop building more incinerators in the UK. The emissions, the impact on climate change, the harm to recycling and the fact it simply isn’t needed all make incineration an expensive folly that we can ill afford. […]

Full Story

UKWIN comment on Eunomia’s incineration overcapacity warning

Eunomia’s Residual Waste Infrastructure Review (12th Issue) is now available via: http://www.eunomia.co.uk/reports-tools/residual-waste-infrastructure-review-12th-issue/ The matter is covered by the BBC in an article entitled: Burning policy puts pressure on recycling targets available from: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-40831628 which reports that: Eunomia’s Dominic Hogg accused the government of withdrawing from waste and resources policy over the last seven years. This has led, he says, to […]

Full Story

Derby waste contract exposed

Long-term waste contracts are often the most expensive contracts a council ever signs, but residents are usually excluded from knowing the details of what has been agreed in their name. One route to obtain this information is through the use of Freedom of Information (FoI) and Environmental Information Regulations (EIR) requests, but in many cases […]

Full Story

UKWIN given Earthmovers award

On Saturday 3rd June 2017 the UK Without Incineration Network (UKWIN) received an Earthmovers Award for Outstanding Community Campaign from Friends of the Earth (FoE) at Basecamp, which is FoE’s annual environmental festival . Accepting the award, UKWIN National Coordinator Shlomo Dowen said: “Over the past decade UKWIN has been blessed with hundreds of dedicated, passionate […]

Full Story

European Parliament’s report calls for halt on harmful subsidies to waste incineration

Press release from Zero Waste Europe Zero Waste Europe welcomes the ENVI committee’s draft report on the revision of the Renewable Energy Directive. This report represents a first important step towards the alignment of EU energy and circular economy policies, by excluding financial support for incineration of mixed municipal solid waste.

Full Story

Annual Incinerator Monitoring Reports for 2016

UKWIN has obtained the full set of Annual Incinerator Monitoring Reports for 2016 from the Environment Agency (EA). These reports are produced by the operators of these facilities and then passed on to the EA. These reports are available from UKWIN’s archive of Annual Incinerator Performance Reports and Permits In an accompanying e-mail message to UKWIN the […]

Full Story
Website crafted by Ben of dowen.me.uk and Josh Dowen, Only Solutions LLP © 2011 UK Without Incineration Network We wish to thank famfamfam.com and OpenClipArt.org for many of the images we have used Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha